Last Updated: 22nd May 2026
12 Most Amazing Butt Plugs According To Reviews
We've compiled a list of the 12 Most Amazing Butt Plugs According To Reviews - May 2026. We put them through their paces to bring you this list of the best on the market.
# 12 Lovehoney - £11.49
Lovehoney Bedtime Bullet 10 Function Vibrating Butt Plug 4 Inch By Lovehoney
Here's an ideal choice for anal play beginners seeking an extra buzz from their butt plug. It may be petite in size, but the 7 intense patterns and 3 speeds will put an arch in your back and add an extra 'oh-my' to your orgasms.
# 11 Cock Locker - £34.99
Cock Locker Inflatable Penis Butt Plug 6 Inch By Cock Locker
Pump up your pleasure with Cock Locker's large inflatable butt plug. Its veiny shaft and realistic head are perfectly shaped to bring you anal gratification with every use, whilst its easy-to-use pump ensures you have total control during playtime.
# 10 Lovehoney BASICS - £9.99
BASICS Slimline P-Spot Butt Plug By Lovehoney BASICS
Perfect for beginners, the BASIC Slimline P-Spot Butt Plug allows you to take control of your anal pleasure. With a tapered tip and flared suction cup base, this smooth little marvel delivers awesome anal sensations.
# 9 Lovehoney - £32.99
Lovehoney Wowzer 7 Function Double Cock Ring and Vibrating Butt Plug By Lovehoney
For millennia man has sought to pair the pleasures of penetration with that of P-spot play. Finally his search ends with the Lovehoney Wowzer Double Cock Ring and Vibrating Butt Plug, the missing sex toy link. Enjoy its arousal in 2 speeds and 5 patterns.
# 8 Lovehoney - £8.49
Lovehoney Super Soft Silicone Rainbow Butt Plug By Lovehoney
Embellish your pot of gold with this glorious rainbow butt plug. Slather this liquid silicone beauty with plenty of anal-safe lube and discover your true colours. Pair it with our matching dildo for double rainbow glory, or purrfect Nyan Cat cosplay.
# 7 nsnovelties - £19.79
Jelly Rancher Pleasure Anal Training Butt Plug Kit (3 Piece) By nsnovelties
Get the all clear when it comes to the rear with this triple set of transparent butt plugs from Jelly Rancher. Crafted into the ultimate shape for safe, pleasurable anal exploration, compatible with all lubes and 3 sizes to choose from.
# 6 Cock Locker - £44.99
Cock Locker Large Inflatable Butt Plug 7.5 Inch By Cock Locker
Expand your horizons (amongst other things) with this jaw-dropping inflatable butt plug from Cock Locker. Made from stretchy latex for balloon-like properties, increase its size with the simple pump for tailored stretch and serious fulfilment.
# 5 Mantric - £34.99
Mantric Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug By Mantric
Blending luxury materials, a powerful motor and ergonomic design, this butt plug is one of a kind. Enjoy super-comfy wear that stays in place thanks to its slender long neck and teardrop body, and powerful, whisper-quiet vibrations from its silicone form.
# 4 TitanMen - £24.99
Doc Johnson TitanMen Master Tool No.4 Butt Plug 6 Inch By TitanMen
With curves that put even Christina Hendricks to shame, this sensually smooth and beefy butt plug offers exceptional stretching sensations for advanced anal explorers. Coat its contours in thick water-based lube to experience its ripples of pleasure.
# 3 TitanMen - £24.99
Doc Johnson Titanmen The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug 6.5 Inch By TitanMen
Phallic anal filling in a smooth and bulbous form, Titamen's heavy-duty butt plug is a Rumpy made for pumpy. Firm but with a cushioned finish for a comfortable fit, this satisfying plug can reach your prostate with ease to trigger incredible orgasms.
# 2 Lovehoney - £34.99
Lovehoney Get Started Beginner's Anal Kit (4 Piece) By Lovehoney
Navigate the beaded, buzzing world of anal play with this beginner's kit. Four toys treat your new bot on the block to nerve-tingling sensations, with added vibrations for that extra-pleasurable oomph. A value-for-money gift for first-timers.
# 1 Lovehoney - £20.69
Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Medium Butt Plug 3 Inch By Lovehoney
Jewel around with this sparkling, silver butt plug. Weighing an impressive 240g, it's a filling treat for your tush. Slather with water-based anal lube and enjoy, as the smooth metal plug bedazzles your booty. Talk about a rock bottom.