Last Updated: 22nd September 2026
16 Most Amazing Butt Plugs According To Reviews
We've compiled a list of the 16 Most Amazing Butt Plugs According To Reviews - September 2026. We put them through their paces to bring you this list of the best on the market.
# 16 Lovehoney - £20.69
Lovehoney Full Bloom Small Rose Glass Butt Plug 3.5 Inch By Lovehoney
Forget a bouquet: with this small, sensual glass butt plug, you only need a single rose to impress. Delicately carved from borosilicate glass with a slim neck and filling 3.75 inch girth, plant this plug in your back garden for splendid pleasure.
# 15 Icicles Glass Sex Toys - £32.27
Icicles No 48 Medium Glass Flower Butt Plug 3 Inch By Icicles Glass Sex Toys
The Icicles No 48 Medium Glass Flower Butt Plug offers safe, temperature-responsive anal play. Made from non-porous Pyrex glass, it features a tapered tip for easy insertion and a flared base for secure comfort. Ideal for beginners, it can be heated or cooled for varied sensory experiences.
# 14 Lovehoney - £11.49
Lovehoney Bedtime Bullet 10 Function Vibrating Butt Plug 4 Inch By Lovehoney
Here's an ideal choice for anal play beginners seeking an extra buzz from their butt plug. It may be petite in size, but the 7 intense patterns and 3 speeds will put an arch in your back and add an extra 'oh-my' to your orgasms.
# 13 Cock Locker - £34.99
Cock Locker Inflatable Penis Butt Plug 6 Inch By Cock Locker
Explore customizable anal play with the Cock Locker Inflatable Penis Butt Plug 6 Inch. This latex toy inflates from 5 to 12 inches in girth, offering realistic aesthetics and adjustable fullness for personalized comfort and sensation.
# 12 Lovehoney BASICS - £9.99
BASICS Slimline P-Spot Butt Plug By Lovehoney BASICS
Flexible PVC P-spot butt plug with flared and suction bases, designed for beginner anal play and prostate stimulation.
# 11 Lovehoney - £32.99
Lovehoney Wowzer 7 Function Double Cock Ring and Vibrating Butt Plug By Lovehoney
For millennia man has sought to pair the pleasures of penetration with that of P-spot play. Finally his search ends with the Lovehoney Wowzer Double Cock Ring and Vibrating Butt Plug, the missing sex toy link. Enjoy its arousal in 2 speeds and 5 patterns.
# 10 Lovehoney - £8.49
Lovehoney Super Soft Silicone Rainbow Butt Plug By Lovehoney
Flexible, waterproof silicone butt plug with a strong suction cup for hands-free play, featuring a beginner-friendly size and vibrant rainbow colors.
# 9 nsnovelties - £19.79
Jelly Rancher Pleasure Anal Training Butt Plug Kit (3 Piece) By nsnovelties
3-piece soft plastic anal training kit with flared bases, suction cups, and progressive sizes for safe, beginner-friendly butt play.
# 8 Cock Locker - £44.99
Cock Locker Large Inflatable Butt Plug 7.5 Inch By Cock Locker
The Cock Locker Large Inflatable Butt Plug uses durable latex and a bulb pump to expand from 6.25 to 14.75 inches in girth. Ideal for progressive stretching, it offers customizable fullness and a flexible, coreless design for intense sensory play.
# 7 Icicles Glass Sex Toys - £25.60
Icicles No 47 Beaded Glass Butt Plug with T-Bar Base By Icicles Glass Sex Toys
Experience graduated pleasure with the Icicles No 47 Beaded Glass Butt Plug. Hand-blown borosilicate glass offers temperature play, safe T-bar base, and smooth, hypoallergenic beads for versatile anal stimulation.
# 6 Mantric - £34.99
Mantric Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug By Mantric
Rechargeable, waterproof, silicone butt plug with multiple vibrations, color-changing controls, and a secure flared base for safe, intense anal pleasure.
# 5 TitanMen - £24.99
Doc Johnson TitanMen Master Tool No.4 Butt Plug 6 Inch By TitanMen
The Doc Johnson TitanMen Master Tool No.4 is an extra-large, firm PVC butt plug for experienced users. Featuring three progressively girthy bulbs up to 8.25 inches and a 6-inch insertable length, it offers intense stretching and fullness with a safe, flared base.
# 4 We-Vibe - £114.84
We-Vibe Vector Custom-Fit 3.9" Prostate Massager With Remote & App By We-Vibe
The We-Vibe Vector is an adjustable, dual-motor prostate massager that targets both the prostate and perineum. App and remote-controlled, it features 10 vibration modes, IPX7 waterproofing, and up to 2 hours of battery life for precise, customizable pleasure.
# 3 TitanMen - £24.99
Doc Johnson Titanmen The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug 6.5 Inch By TitanMen
The Doc Johnson Titanmen The Rumpy Smooth Butt Plug is a large, non-vibrating PVC anal toy with a 6.5-inch insertable length and 7-inch circumference. It features a realistic phallic head, a bulbous shaft for prostate stimulation, and a flared base for safety.
# 2 Lovehoney - £34.99
Lovehoney Get Started Beginner's Anal Kit (4 Piece) By Lovehoney
Explore anal play safely with the Lovehoney Get Started Beginner's Anal Kit (4 Piece). This set includes a butt plug, probe, vibrating beads, and vibrating plug, all featuring tapered tips and flared bases for easy, secure insertion.
# 1 Lovehoney - £20.69
Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Medium Butt Plug 3 Inch By Lovehoney
Experience firm, weighty stimulation with the Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Medium Butt Plug. This 3-inch zinc alloy plug features a sparkling gem base, temperature play capability, and a 4.5-inch girth for deep, satisfying fullness.